Talking about God

This morning on the way to preschool, N was looking into a neighbor’s yard and stated, “Mom, everyone has that girl in their yards but not including us.”  (Meaning “except for us.”)  She pointed to the Virgin Mary statue on the neighbor’s lawn.

“Well, sweetie,” I responded, “that’s Mary.  She’s Jesus’ mommy.  You’re right that many people in this neighborhood have a statue of her in their yard, but we don’t.”

“But I want her in our yard,” N said.

“Well,” I said slowly, trying to think a couple of steps ahead in this conversation.  “Some people have Mary in their yards because of their religion.  Religion means what people believe about God.  It’s not my religion to have Mary in our yard.”

“But I want her in our yard,” N repeated.

“Honey, we’re not getting a statue in our yard. ”  Then I figured some clarification was in order.  “I do like Mary, and I like God a lot.  In fact, I think he’s awesome.  He made the sky, the trees, the birds, and even us.”

N thought for a moment, then asked — with a touch of skepticism — “How could God possibly make the sky if he’s down on the ground?”

“That’s a great question, honey.  I believe God lives in the sky.”

“But…how could God possibly make us if he lives in the sky?”

(Apparently “possibly” is the word of the week.)

I sighed.  “Those are terrific questions, honey.  In fact, grownups don’t even have all the answers to questions about God.  So just keep asking them your whole life.”

I suppose we’ll start taking this questioning kid to church, so she can check out God for herself.  My parents never pushed religion on me, and we don’t intend to do so with our girls either.  But it’s time we introduce the concept and let N explore for herself.

As long as I don’t wind up with a Virgin Mary in a bathtub on my lawn.





About A Mom In Brooklyn

A mom in Brooklyn
This entry was posted in Parenting, Religion. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Talking about God

  1. Anonymous says:

    Nanny would be proud.

  2. Anonymous says:

    I remember our religious discussions back in school. Those were some wonderful debates! Glad to see she has your inquisitive nature; it’s the best way to learn. I have found some very beautiful paintings of Mary and her divine infant. This is my way of compromising with my sorta-Catholic hubby. He sees the religiously dictated Mother of Jesus while I view them as a depiction of motherhood and all that is gloriously feminine. Hey, they are pretty…aesthetics counts for something!
    Wishing you well!

    • And I remember your eye for beauty and creative expression! I love your view of Mary as a symbol of motherhood and the divine feminine — something our society doesn’t value highly enough, in my humble opinion!

      Actually N and I had a few follow-up conversations about God, and she asked if God is a boy or a girl. I told her that some people believe God is a boy and some believe a girl, but that she can believe whatever she wants. She said she thinks God is “a mommy and a daddy.” I thought that was a pretty good approach!!

  3. Anonymous says:

    Hilarious Julie… teach us what you figure out as we are clueless and have managed to avoid this topic head on so far!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s